Home Uncategorized Do Green Initiatives Conflict with AAA, Mobil Rating Criteria?

Do Green Initiatives Conflict with AAA, Mobil Rating Criteria?


I need your help for a future column. I am curious to know if your property or restaurant has ever had its rating affected negatively in any way by a AAA or Mobil inspector because of one of your energy-, water-, or waste-saving initiatives. The purpose of my query is not to accumulate ammunition to shoot at AAA, or Forbes (which publishes the guides in which hotels are Mobil rated) but to come up with a list of suggestions for improvement if such a list is needed. I have become aware of instances where green initiatives have come into conflict with rating criteria. I will address those examples in future columns.

I just read through the various criteria for AAA’s Diamond Rating Guidelines, as well as the Lodging Star Criteria for the Mobil star rating system. Based on those two lists, it is clear that both programs have not yet reached the point where they are actually rewarding green lodging initiatives—AAA is acknowledging, yes, but rewarding, no. I am not suggesting that it is AAA or Forbes’ role to evaluate a property’s environmental practices. AAA’s Diamond Rating Guidelines mention “green” just twice: acknowledging implementation of optional towel/linen replacement programs by housekeeping; and at the very end of its Guidelines where it includes a paragraph supportive of “Green Programs.”

AAA’s paragraph reads: “AAA supports environmental management and sustainability throughout the hospitality industry to the extent that truly effective programs maintain quality standards of guest comfort. We strongly encourage continued use of programs that offer guests choices without consequences for noncompliance. Effective green programs are intended to reduce waste without reducing guest comfort.” AAA includes this statement in its Diamond Rating Guidelines for restaurants as well. I searched through Mobil’s Lodging Star Criteria and star rating process for restaurants and did not find one single mention of green programs.

In early October, AAA announced that it would launch a program to highlight AAA Approved lodgings that have been eco-certified through a well-established government or private program. A bright green “ECO” symbol makes it easy to identify eco-friendly lodgings in the new 2010 editions of the AAA TourBook guides and on AAA.com. Additionally, travelers are able to customize their hotel searches on AAA.com to show green properties first in their search results. Forbes has not yet taken a similar step with its guides. It is obvious that AAA is at least showing a strong interest in green programs.

If your property or restaurant has ever had its AAA or Mobil rating negatively impacted because of what you perceive to be a green initiative, I would like to know about it. Call (440) 243-2055 or e-mail editor@greenlodgingnews.com. I will share your input with readers in future columns. Thank you.

Green Lodging News Welcomes Plan A as Directory Partner

Green Lodging News welcomes Plan A Public Relations & Marketing as a Green Product & Service Directory partner. Plan A Public Relations & Marketing is a full-service advertising and public relations firm, specializing in suppliers of sustainable solutions for the hospitality industry. With more than 25 years experience, Plan A offers a full range of marketing services, including public relations, branding, creative and media strategies. Andrea Roland is the president of Plan A. Her team includes Diane Van Leunen, art director, Ryan Marks, public relations specialist, and Sheila Folk, traffic manager/office manager. For more information, call (407) 905-0608, e-mail andrea@planapr.com, or go to www.planapr.com.

Upcoming Green Lodging & Hospitality Conference in Orlando

I will be on a panel focused on greenwashing at the Green Lodging & Hospitality Conference in Orlando, Fla., on Wednesday, December 9. For information on this event, give me a call at (440) 243-2055, e-mail me at editor@greenlodgingnews.com, or click here to access the conference itinerary.

Get in the Spotlight in 2010

Green Lodging News has been publishing the Green Supplier Spotlight each Wednesday since mid-2008. The e-blast reaches the list of Green Lodging News subscribers that currently stands at 10,965. If your company has a product or products it would like to feature in the e-mail Spotlight in 2010, be sure to contact me soon, as Wednesdays are filling up quickly. Call me at (440) 243-2055, or contact me by e-mail at editor@greenlodgingnews.com. Additional ad spots are also available for the remainder of 2009. A 2010 media kit is available by request or by clicking here. Thank you to all of those companies that consistently support Green Lodging News.

Green Lodging News Blog & Twitter

Be sure to bookmark the Green Lodging News Blog in your browser. The address for the blog is http://greenlodgingnews.blogspot.com. More importantly, participate with your comments. Green Lodging News is also now on Twitter. To follow my postings, go to http://twitter.com/greenlodging. Be sure to add Green Lodging News to those tweets that you follow. Green Lodging News now has 302 Twitter followers.

As always, I can be reached at editor@greenlodgingnews.com.