Home Air Quality Group Urges USVI to Stop Incineration of Hurricane Debris

Group Urges USVI to Stop Incineration of Hurricane Debris


JOHN, USVI—As the U.S. Virgin Islands (USVI) picks up the pieces from the ravages of two back-to-back Category 5 hurricanes, Island Green Living Assn. is urgently pleading with Governor Mapp and members of the legislature to resist pressure from FEMA and the US Army Corp of Engineers and ban the incineration of hurricane debris. Most of the debris is clean wood from fallen trees, limbs and other vegetation. FEMA and the US Army Corp of Engineers have influenced the governor to reverse his original stance and the potential health and environmental implications of local burning, a process that will take a year or more. According to Island Green Living Assn., the burning will emit harmful chemicals and strip the islands of rich organic material that the soil and plants need to flourish.

Island Green Living Assn. has introduced a petition to convince Governor Mapp to stand by his original decision not to incinerate. The organization urges residents and others interested in the health and environmental wellbeing of the USVI to sign this petition. In addition, residents can call and write the governor (340-774-0001) and members of the USVI Legislature (Senator Myron D. Jackson: mjackson@legvi.org).

At a town hall meeting hosted by Senate President Myron D. Jackson at the Legislature building on St. John, Army Corp of Engineers confirmed their intention to burn. Currently, FEMA plans to burn the wood at Coral Bay on St. John, St Thomas (TBD) and Body Slob on St. Croix.

The past practice of FEMA and the Army Corp of Engineers in situations like this is air-curtain incineration and they have proposed it in the USVI as well. Air-curtain incinerators are basically large metal containers with fans on the bottom to accelerate the combustion process. There are no pollution controls and particulate matter and other air pollutants are often emitted on hot and humid days—which is common in the USVI.

Permits Need to Be Secured

Before burning can proceed, permits need to be secured from the department of Planning and Natural Resources. During Superstorm Sandy, EPA Region 2 conducted air monitoring, which must also be performed in the USVI. After Sandy, the burning happened on federal land in Brooklyn, N.Y. with the nearest home .08 miles away. The Army Corp of Engineers planned to burn for four months but stopped after one month.

Island Green Living Assn. says it is absolutely critical that vegetative material from the hurricanes be kept on the islands and composted. Composting experts from the USVI and stateside have worked together to develop a chipping/composting/mulching plan that will ensure the debris management process is done safely and efficiently, resulting in organic mulch that can be made available to local residents, farms, schools and businesses for free. This is a process that nature has perfected over millions of years and one that has been successful in many locations, and at large scales, including in subtropical/tropical areas like the islands, and with other disasters (like Superstorm Sandy).

The USVI is a sensitive tropical ecosystem with high temperatures and high humidity. Many residents of the USVI have asthma and other respiratory and cardiac diseases that are made worse by air pollution. The operation of diesel generators and exposure to indoor mold caused by the storms are already aggravating existing respiratory diseases. It is an understatement to say that the air quality would be severely impacted if burning were allowed to happen—a severe detriment to health and to the number one industry—tourism.